- Design
- Food
- Pop Culture
- Style
- DIY Classes
The Best Carbon Steel Pans To Cook Mouthwatering Steaks
Imagine preparing a delicate fish fillet or striving for the perfect crust on a steak, only to have it burn. Many people struggle with pans that either stick, don't heat evenly, or wear out too quickly. It's a common problem, leading to ruined dishes. Unsurprisingly, the quest for a pan that can transition from stove to oven is ongoing. There are many pans on the market, yet finding a pan that ticks all the boxes remains a challenge. Oh, and let's not even mention pans that warp after a few high-heat sessions. This is where the best carbon steel pans shine. Moreover, the Merten & Storck Carbon Steel Pan is known for its superior heat conduction, exceptional durability, and non-stick qualities that improve with age. Want options? You’ll find our top picks below!
Important Features- Lightweight and quick-heating carbon steel
- Non-stick patina development with use
- Oven-safe up to 600°F
- Triple-riveted steel handle
- Metal utensil safe
Important Features- Excellent heat retention for browning and frying
- Superior flat base stability
- Sloped sides offer easy tossing and sautéing
- Angled ergonomic handle
- Compatible with all cooking surfaces, including induction
Important Features- Large 12-inch size
- Includes silicone hot handle holder
- Heavy-duty 12-gauge carbon steel
- Steel riveted handles
- Great for induction cooktops
Important Features- Traditional, steel-welded French handle
- Naturally non-stick after seasoning
- No chemicals or synthetic coating
- Lighter than cast iron
- Rooted in French culinary tradition
Important Features- Durable, long-lasting carbon steel construction
- Excellent heat conduction for even cooking
- Compatible with gas burners and open fire
- Available in vibrant red and classic silver
5 Best Carbon Steel Pans of 2024
The Merten & Storck Carbon Steel Pan combines the robustness of cast iron with the convenience of non-stick ceramic. The pre-seasoned surface means that with each use, it becomes more non-stick, offering a natural, evolving cooking surface that enhances flavors and reduces the need for added fats. Moreover, this pan’s lightweight design makes moving it from the stovetop and into the oven easy. Additionally, its compatibility with gas, electric, and induction stovetops adds a layer of versatility, catering to a wide range of kitchen setups.
What’s more, the pan can withstand temperatures up to 600°F, making it perfect for recipes that start on the stove and finish in the oven. Further, the durability of carbon steel, combined with a metal utensil-safe surface, allows you to use your favorite utensils without the worry of damage. Likewise, the triple-riveted steel handle ensures a secure grip, making the transfer of food safe and easy. This carbon still pan earned the “Best Overall” award on our list due to its superior combination of versatile stovetop compatibility and an evolving non-stick surface, distinguishing itself in both functionality and convenience.
Pros- Lightweight, easy to handle
- Grows more non-stick with use
- Oven-safe up to 600°F
- Works on all stovetops
Cons- Only available in two styles
The Ballarini Carbon Steel Pan marries the traditional charm of Italian craftsmanship with modern needs. Its thick construction ensures durability that withstands the rigors of daily use. Moreover, its superior heat retention rivals that of cast iron, enabling perfect browning and frying without the heft, making it an ideal choice for those seeking lightweight pans. Additionally, the pan boasts superior flat base stability. This coupled with sloped side walls, facilitates effortless tossing and sautéing.
What’s more, the angled handles further contribute to its ergonomic design, offering a comfortable grip during use. It’s also compatible with all stovetops, including induction. Furthermore, being oven-safe up to 600˚F opens the door to a wide range of cooking techniques, from stovetop to oven. Lastly, the sleek steel color of the pan adds a touch of elegance to any kitchen décor.
Pros- Durable, thick construction withstands daily use
- Sloped sides for easy tossing and sautéing
- Compatible with all cooking surfaces, including induction
- Oven-safe up to 600˚F
Cons- Not everyone has a preference for the design
The Lodge Carbon Steel Frying Pan offers a heavy-duty 12 gauge carbon steel construction, ensuring durability and efficient heat distribution. Moreover, seasoned for a natural, easy-release finish, this skillet only gets better with use. Furthermore, its compatibility with induction cooktops adds a layer of versatility, catering to a wide range of cooking methods.
Safety-wise, the silicone hot handle holder is a thoughtful addition, protecting hands from heat up to 500˚F. The steel riveted handles enhance the skillet’s robustness and longevity, ensuring it can handle the rigors of daily cooking with ease. Most noteworthy, its capacity to sauté, grill, roast, and fry with proficiency makes it an invaluable pan in the kitchen. As a bonus, its stylish black and orange color scheme adds a touch of elegance to any kitchen decor.
Pros- Durable 12-gauge carbon steel construction
- Compatible with induction cooktops, versatile
- Silicone handle holder protects up to 500°F
- Stylish black & orange design
Cons- Only available in one style and color, yet practical
The De Buyer Blue Carbon Steel Frying Pan stands out for its exceptional heat conductivity, making it a superb choice for crepes, tortillas, and pancakes. Moreover, this pan is designed to improve with use, developing a better non-stick quality over time. Likewise, its lightweight nature, compared to cast iron, facilitates easy handling and flipping, which is crucial when preparing delicate dishes like crepes.
Construction-wise, the steel-welded French handle is carefully crafted to keep your hand comfortably away from the heat, promoting safety alongside convenience. Additionally, the pan’s durability, rooted in the traditional French culinary craftsmanship of De Buyer, promises a long-lasting addition to your kitchen. Lastly, it’s available in a sleek black color, adding a classic French appeal to your kitchen.
Pros- Naturally non-stick, improves with use
- Lightweight, easier to handle than cast iron
- Durable, long-lasting French craftsmanship
- Safe, traditional French handle design
Cons- Hand-wash only
The Machika pan’s exceptional heat conductivity stands out, courtesy of its thin material, ensuring your dishes are cooked evenly and to perfection. Further, the polished surface with dimples aids in distributing heat across the pan. Versatility-wise, this pan isn’t just for paella; from sizzling pizzas and fluffy pancakes to succulent pork and vibrant vegetarian feasts, the possibilities are endless. It’s also perfect for outdoor gatherings, camping, or a quiet dinner at home. Additionally, its compatibility with various cooking equipment, including gas burners and open fires, enhances its use.
Likewise, maintenance is easy with this pan. A simple wash, thorough drying, and a light coating of vegetable oil keep it looking new. As a bonus, it’s available in eye-catching red and silver, perfect kitchen colors.
Pros- Sturdy and durable design
- Ensures evenly cooked meals
- Low maintenance with simple care instructions
- Available in attractive color options
Cons- Budget-friendly option
Choosing the Best Carbon Steel Pan: A User's Guide
A Quality Carbon Steel Frying Pan Can Last a Lifetime
Many of us face the dilemma of investing in cookware that barely survives a few years. The frustration is real. Uneven heating, sticking food, and the dreaded rust spots that seem to appear out of nowhere. Thankfully, a quality carbon steel pan boasts superior heat distribution. And the best part? With the right care, this pan is in it for the long haul—literally a lifetime. Moreover, these pans only get better with age. Like a fine wine, a carbon steel pan develops its own unique seasoning, becoming more non-stick over time. This means easier cooking and cleaning.
Additionally, let’s not forget the versatility. Searing, baking, broiling—you name it, the carbon steel pan does it. Its ability to withstand incredibly high temperatures makes it a star not just on the stove but in the oven as well. My favorite pan is the Merten & Storck Carbon Steel Pan. It’s lightweight and boasts an affordable price tag.
7 Benefits of Using a Carbon Steel Pan
- Excellent heat conduction: heats up quickly and evenly, perfect for uniform cooking.
- High heat tolerance: suitable for very high temperatures without degrading.
- Durability: extremely durable, often lasting a lifetime with proper care.
- Versatility: great for searing, frying, grilling, and even baking.
- Naturally non-stick over time: develops a non-stick surface with seasoning, reducing the need for added fats.
- Lightweight compared to cast iron: easier to handle, making it user-friendly when cooking.
- Cost-effective: offers great value for its durability and multifunctional use.
What You Need to Consider When Choosing a Quality Carbon Steel Frying Pan
1. Material
Carbon steel pans are made from an alloy of iron and carbon, making them ideal for high-heat cooking. So, look for pans made from high-quality carbon steel, which offers excellent heat conductivity and durability. Moreover, a well-constructed carbon steel pan should have a smooth surface.
2. Size
Consider your cooking needs and the number of people you typically cook for when choosing the size of your pan. Sizes typically range from 8 – 14 inches in diameter. Of course, a larger pan is ideal for cooking larger quantities, while a smaller pan is suitable for single servings or smaller dishes.
3. Construction
Opt for a carbon steel frying pan with a thick gauge, as it provides better heat distribution and retention. Naturally, a sturdy construction ensures the pan won’t warp or dent easily, even with prolonged use at high temperatures.
4. Heat Conductivity
One of the standout features of carbon steel pans is their exceptional heat conductivity. Look for pans that distribute heat evenly across the cooking surface, allowing for precise temperature control and consistent cooking results. Likewise, the pan should also retain heat well, ensuring your food stays warm even after removing it from the heat source.
5. Durability
A high-quality pan should be resistant to warping, cracking, and flaking. Moreover, check for pans with reinforced edges and sturdy construction to ensure they can withstand frequent use and high temperatures without compromising their integrity.
6. Non-stick Properties
Carbon steel frying pans develop a natural non-stick surface called seasoning, which improves with each use. Look for pans that come pre-seasoned or are easy to season. Seasoning creates a protective layer that enhances the non-stick properties, making it easier to cook delicate foods without them sticking to the surface.
7. Versatility
Consider how you plan to use your carbon steel pan. Look for pans that are suitable for multiple cooking methods, such as stovetop, oven, and grill. This versatility allows you to experiment with different recipes and cooking techniques.
8. Weight
The weight of a carbon steel pan is an important factor to consider, especially if you do a lot of cooking. Consider pans that are balanced and manageable, ensuring comfortable and easy handling while cooking. However, keep in mind that carbon steel pans are generally heavier than non-stick pans due to their sturdier construction.
9. Handle
The handle of a carbon steel pan should be ergonomic and heat-resistant for safe and comfortable gripping. Consider pans with handles that stay cool during stovetop cooking and have a secure attachment to the pan. Helper handles or loop handles can also make it easier to lift and maneuver the pan.
10. Seasoning
As mentioned earlier, seasoning plays a crucial role in the non-stick performance of carbon steel pans. Pre-seasoned pans come with a head start, but even if you opt for an unseasoned pan, it should be easy to season at home. Most importantly, follow the manufacturer’s instructions or search for reliable seasoning techniques to ensure your pan develops a durable and effective non-stick coating.
11. Compatibility
If you have an induction cooktop, ensure that the carbon steel frying pan you choose is induction-ready. Additionally, check that the pan is compatible with all other cooktops, including gas, electric, and ceramic.
12. Maintenance
Carbon steel pans require proper care and maintenance to ensure their longevity. They need to be oiled regularly. Also, avoid using harsh detergents that can strip the seasoning. Moreover, wipe the pan dry and lightly oil the surface after each use to maintain its non-stick properties.
The Merten & Storck Carbon Steel Pan Is Not Just a Purchase but an Investment
In wrapping up, it’s clear that the Merten & Storck Carbon Steel Pan is far more than just a pan; it’s an investment. And not just any investment, but one that pays off with every use. You see, unlike poor-quality cookware, the more you use it, the more seasoned it becomes, adding a deeper, more savory flavor to each meal. Its unmatched durability means you’re not just investing in a pan for today but for many tomorrows.
Lastly, let’s not forget practicality. In an era where conscious consumerism is more important than ever, opting for a high-quality pan means fewer replacements and less waste. I know you will value the Merten & Storck Carbon Steel Pan as much as all the happy customers who invested in it do!
Carbon Steel Pan FAQs
Q: What's the best way to cook a steak in the Merten Carbon Steel Pan?A: Preheat your Merten & Storck Carbon Steel Pan until very hot, then cook your steak for 2-3 minutes on each side for a medium-rare finish, seasoning with salt and pepper. Let it rest for a few minutes before serving to allow the juices to redistribute.
Q: Can you make fried eggs in a carbon steel pan?A: Yes, you can make fried eggs in a carbon steel frying pan. Ensure the pan is well-seasoned and preheated over medium heat with a little oil or butter to prevent sticking and achieve a perfectly cooked egg.
Q: Is a carbon steel frying pan easy to use?A: A carbon steel frying pan is easy to use once seasoned properly. It requires a bit of maintenance to maintain its non-stick properties, but its superior heat conductivity and versatility in cooking different foods make it an invaluable pan in the kitchen.
Q: Is the Merten Carbon Steel Pan worth the investment?A: The Merten & Storck Carbon Steel Pan is worth the investment for those who value high heat tolerance and the ability to achieve a professional sear on meats. Its durability and improved cooking performance over time justify its cost for home cooks.
Q: What are good carbon steel pan options on a budget?A: For those looking for a quality yet affordable pan, the Merten & Storck Carbon Steel Pan offers great value. It's affordable, durable, and highly rated.
Q: How does a carbon steel frying pan differ from a ceramic pan?A: Carbon steel frying pans offer high heat tolerance and require seasoning to enhance their non-stick properties, making them ideal for searing and browning. Ceramic pans, on the other hand, naturally have non-stick surfaces without the need for seasoning, are easy to clean, but are less durable and have a lower heat tolerance.
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase through one of our links. The newsroom or editorial staff was not involved in the creation of this content.